The Virtual Compliance Assistant’s form generator will undergo maintenance from September 26th at 8pm PT to September 27th at 4am PT. During this time, you will have access to your projects but will not be able to export Compliance Forms. We apologize for any inconvenience.
Appendix JA3   Time Dependent Valuation (TDV)
JA3.1 Scope and Purpose

 Energy Budget is the maximum energy consumption that a proposed building, or portion of a building, 

can be designed to consume, calculated using Commission-approved compliance software as specified 

by the Alternative Calculation Method Approval Manual. The Energy Budget for newly constructed 

single-family, multifamily, and nonresidential buildings are expressed in terms of the Long-Term 

System Cost (LSC) and Source Energy. The Energy Budget for additions and alterations for all 

building types are expressed in terms of LSC.


JA3.1.1 Long-Term System Cost (LSC)

LSC consists of large data sets that convert electricity, gas and propane to LSC energy. The rate 

of conversion varies for each hour of the year, for each climate zone and for each energy type 

(electricity, natural gas and propane). The conversion factors also vary by building type: low-rise 

residential and other building types, including nonresidential, hotel/motel and high-rise 

residential. There are a total of 96 hourly data sets (16 climate zones x 3 fuel types x 2 building 

types) where the 2 building types are residential 30 year and nonresidential 30 year. The complete 

LSC data can be downloaded from the Energy Commission’s website.

Because of the length, the actual data is not published in this appendix.

LSC is also used to evaluate the cost effectiveness of measures and to perform other codes 

analysis.

JA3.1.2 Source Energy

Source energy is the long run marginal source energy of fossil fuels that are combusted as a result 

of building energy consumed either directly at the building site or caused to be consumed to meet 

the electrical demand of the building considering the long-term marginal hourly resources of 

Commission-projected electric system resource procurement. For a given hour, the value in that hour 

for each forecasted year is averaged to get a lifetime average source energy.

The complete Source Energy data can be downloaded from the Energy Commission’s

website. Because of the length, the actual data is not published in this appendix.

JA3.2 Summary of Data

Table 3-1 through Table 3-6 give a statistical summary of the LSC and source energy factors for 

electricity, natural gas and propane. Each table has the annual minimum,

maximum, and average for each climate zone and building type.


(a) Table 3-1 – LSC Statistical Data – Electricity ($/kWh)

(b) Table 3-2 – LSC Statistical Data – Natural Gas ($/Therm)

(c) Table 3-3 – LSC Statistical Data – Propane ($/Therm)

(d) Table 3-4 – Source Energy Statistical Data – Electricity (kBtu/KWh)

(e) Table 3-5 – Source Energy Statistical Data – Natural Gas

(f) Table 3-6 – Source Energy Statistical Data – Propane




Table 3-1 – LSC Statistical Data – Electricity ($/kWh)

Climate Zone

Residential Minimum

Residential Average

Residential Maximum

Nonresidential Minimum

Nonresidential Average

Nonresidential Maximum

1

4.37

6.71

53.70

3.24

5.63

53.78

2

4.37

6.71

60.38

3.24

5.64

60.57

3

4.37

6.71

50.85

3.24

5.64

50.89

4

4.37

6.70

50.82

3.23

5.63

50.82

5

4.37

6.71

50.85

3.24

5.64

50.89

6

4.57

6.74

52.22

3.43

5.66

52.33

7

4.21

6.67

133.66

3.11

5.60

133.57

8

4.55

6.72

51.24

3.42

5.65

51.33

9

4.55

6.72

51.24

3.42

5.65

54.28

10

4.55

6.72

41.52

3.42

5.64

51.50

11

4.37

6.71

50.82

3.23

5.63

50.81

12

4.37

6.71

50.82

3.24

5.63

50.84

13

4.36

6.70

50.80

3.23

5.63

50.81

14

4.55

6.71

51.22

3.42

5.64

51.30

15

4.54

6.71

51.18

3.41

5.64

51.29

16

4.58

6.75

51.35

3.42

5.65

51.36

 

 

Table 3-2 – LSC Statistical Data – Natural Gas ($/therm)

Climate Zone

Residential Minimum

Residential Average

Residential Maximum

Residential Minimum

Residential Average

Residential Maximum

1

113.07

119.05

127.10

46.51

53.23

62.33

2

113.07

119.05

127.10

46.51

53.23

62.33

3

113.07

119.05

127.10

46.51

53.23

62.33

4

113.07

119.05

127.10

46.51

53.23

62.33

5

113.07

119.05

127.10

46.51

53.23

62.33

6

113.10

119.21

127.44

46.54

53.59

63.16

7

113.12

119.45

128.00

46.55

53.78

63.59

8

113.10

119.21

127.44

46.54

53.59

63.16

9

113.10

119.21

127.44

46.54

53.59

63.16

10

113.10

119.21

127.44

46.54

53.59

63.16

11

113.07

119.05

127.10

46.51

53.23

62.33

12

113.07

119.05

127.10

46.51

53.23

62.33

13

113.07

119.05

127.10

46.51

53.23

62.33

14

113.10

119.21

127.44

46.54

53.59

63.16

15

113.10

119.21

127.44

46.54

53.59

63.16

16

113.07

119.05

127.10

46.54

53.59

63.16

 


 

 





















.

Table 3-3 – LSC Statistical Data – Propane ($/therm)

Climate Zone

Residential Minimum

Residential Average

Residential Maximum

Nonresidential Minimum

Nonresidential Average

Nonresidential Maximum

1

92.50

101.65

111.51

75.97

82.76

90.07

2

92.50

101.65

111.51

75.97

82.76

90.07

3

92.50

101.65

111.51

75.97

82.76

90.07

4

92.50

101.65

111.51

75.97

82.76

90.07

5

92.50

101.65

111.51

75.97

82.76

90.07

6

92.50

101.65

111.51

75.97

82.76

90.07

7

92.50

101.65

111.51

75.97

82.76

90.07

8

92.50

101.65

111.51

75.97

82.76

90.07

9

92.50

101.65

111.51

75.97

82.76

90.07

10

92.50

101.65

111.51

75.97

82.76

90.07

11

92.50

101.65

111.51

75.97

82.76

90.07

12

92.50

101.65

111.51

75.97

82.76

90.07

13

92.50

101.65

111.51

75.97

82.76

90.07

14

92.50

101.65

111.51

75.97

82.76

90.07

15

92.50

101.65

111.51

75.97

82.76

90.07

16

92.50

101.65

111.51

75.97

82.76

90.07

 

Table 3-4 – Source Energy Statistical Data – Electricity (kBtu/kWh)

Climate Zone

Residential Minimum

Residential Average

Residential Maximum

Nonresidential Minimum

Nonresidential Average

Nonresidential Maximum

1

0.0036

1.70

8.67

0.0036

1.70

8.67

2

0.0036

1.70

8.67

0.0036

1.70

8.67

3

0.0036

1.70

8.67

0.0036

1.70

8.67

4

0.0036

1.70

8.67

0.0036

1.70

8.67

5

0.0036

1.70

8.67

0.0036

1.70

8.67

6

0.0036

1.70

8.67

0.0036

1.70

8.67

7

0.0036

1.70

8.67

0.0036

1.70

8.67

8

0.0036

1.70

8.67

0.0036

1.70

8.67

9

0.0036

1.70

8.67

0.0036

1.70

8.67

10

0.0036

1.70

8.67

0.0036

1.70

8.67

11

0.0036

1.70

8.67

0.0036

1.70

8.67

12

0.0036

1.70

8.67

0.0036

1.70

8.67

13

0.0036

1.70

8.67

0.0036

1.70

8.67

14

0.0036

1.70

8.67

0.0036

1.70

8.67

15

0.0036

1.70

8.67

0.0036

1.70

8.67

16

0.0036

1.70

8.67

0.0036

1.70

8.67

 

 

 

Table 3-5 – Source Energy Statistical Data – Natural Gas (kBtu/Therm)

Climate Zone

Residential Minimum

Residential Average

Residential Maximum

Nonresidential Minimum

Nonresidential Average

Nonresidential Maximum

1

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

2

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

3

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

4

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

5

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

6

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

7

89.64

89.64

89.64

89.64

89.64

89.64

8

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

9

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

10

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

11

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

12

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

13

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

90.54

14

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

15

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

16

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

89.96

 

 

 

Table 3-6 – Source Energy Statistical Data – Propane (kBtu/Therm)

Climate Zone

Residential Minimum

Residential Average

Residential Maximum

Nonresidential Minimum

Nonresidential Average

Nonresidential Maximum

1

100

100

100

100

100

100

2

100

100

100

100

100

100

3

100

100

100

100

100

100

4

100

100

100

100

100

100

5

100

100

100

100

100

100

6

100

100

100

100

100

100

7

100

100

100

100

100

100

8

100

100

100

100

100

100

9

100

100

100

100

100

100

10

100

100

100

100

100

100

11

100

100

100

100

100

100

12

100

100

100

100

100

100

13

100

100

100

100

100

100

14

100

100

100

100

100

100

15

100

100

100

100

100

100

16

100

100

100

100

100

100

 

 

 


loading